The 8 Witnesses – Can We Trust Their Testimonies?

I am going to start by repeated my opening statement that I made in my article pertaining to the 3 Witnesses:

“When talking about the reliability of Joseph Smith’s testimony of the gold plates and the Book of Mormon, a big pillar of truth for LDS members is what is written in the first couple pages of the Book of Mormon: the testimony of the 3 witnesses and the testimony of the 8 witnesses. Bible based Christians will often claim that one of the best reasons to believe in the resurrection is the fact that we have eyewitnesses who saw the risen Christ and then wrote about it. These written testimonies are in our Bible today. Latter Day Saints like to draw the same comparison in regard to the witnesses of the gold plates. Let’s compare these two groups and see where the evidence leads. Let’s start by listing the witnesses of the gold plates and their relation to Joseph Smith:

  1. Martin Harris – JS’s business associate (sold his farm to publish BOM. Would have lost everything if the BOM plan failed. Very financially motivated for it to succeed)
  2. Oliver Cowdry – JS’s cousin
  3. Jospeh Smith Sr – JS’s father
  4. Samuel Smith – JS’s brother
  5. Hyrum Smith – JS’s brother
  6. John Whitmer – Brother of David Whitmer.
  7. Jacob Whitmer – Brother of David Whitmer.
  8. Christian Whitmer – Brother of David Whitmer.
  9. Peter Whitmer – Brother of David Whitmer.
  10. David Whitmer – Close friend with Cowdry.
  11. Hiram Page – David Whitmer’s brother in-law

First thing right off the bat that we have to recognize is that all of these people are related to Joseph Smith either by blood or by business. Because of these tight connections, a skeptic might call out the obvious possibility of collusion.”

__________________________________________________________________________

In a nutshell, there are a number of statements given by the 8 witnesses that indicate they only saw the angel and the plates in a visionary experience. But this begs the question: If the gold plates were real, why would these witnesses need to see them in a vision when the gold plates were physically here on earth in Joseph Smith’s possession?

There are also several statements of the witnesses saying that they only saw the plates when they were covered with a cloth. It is also important to note that by 1847, not a single one of the surviving eleven witnesses was part of the LDS Church. Of the 8 witnesses, we only have clear quotations from 2 of them that we can glean from. Let’s begin examining their statements:

John Whitmer. “I now say, I handled those plates; there were fine engravings on both sides. …they were shown to me by a supernatural power.” (History of the Church, Vol. 3, p. 307) Again, why would a supernatural power be necessary if the plates physically existed in Joseph Smith’s house? Why wouldn’t Smith simply invite them inside to take a look at the gold plates?

Marvin Hill (faithful LDS historian) commented on a letter written by Hiram Page to the Ensign of Liberty in 1848. In it, Page defended his belief that the Book of Mormon was a work of the Lord. However, Hill conceded that Page did not actually say he saw the plates:

“With only a veiled reference to ‘what I saw,’ Page does not say he saw the plates but that angels confirmed him in his faith. Neither does he say that any coercion was placed upon him to secure his testimony. Despite Page’s inconsistencies, it is difficult to know what to make of Harris’ affirmation that the eight saw no plates in the face of John Whitmer’s testimony.”

This last one is related to Martin Harris. I know Harris isn’t in the category of the 8 witnesses, but the importance of this detail makes it worth mentioning. Stephen Burnett was ordained an elder by John Whitmer and ordained a high priest by Oliver Cowdry. Burnett wrote a letter to Lyman E. Johnson in 1838 and makes mention of Martin Harris. In this letter, Burnett reported that Harris once told him that,

“he had hefted the plates repeatedly in a box with only a tablecloth or a handkerchief over them, but he never saw them only as he saw a city through a mountain. And said that he never should have told that the testimony of the eight was false.”

Burnett went on to say,

“I am well satisfied for myself that if the witnesses whose names are attached to the Book of Mormon never saw the plates as Martin admits that there can be nothing brought to prove that any such thing ever existed.”

Needless to say, Burnett apostatized and was excommunicated from the Church. But I think I think it is super important to note why he left. It was because of the very topic we are discussing. Being very close to Martin Harris, listening to the things he said, and realizing that the 11 witnesses are nothing more than a group of people who claim to have had a spiritual visionary experience of seeing gold plates. He realized how shady that is and it understandably broke his faith.

When latter day saints today grow up with the visualization that the witnesses physically handled the plates as the Book of Mormon testimonies state, and that the 8 witnesses saw the gold plates on a tree stump and each turn turns flipping the gold pages, it can be a very brutal wake up call when they realize that this is not at all how it happened. Yet there are pictures on the LDS Church website depicting that this is how it happened.

This similar situation is applicable to Joseph Smith translating the gold plates. Many Latter Day Saints grew up believing what is portrayed on the Church website today: a picture of Smith sitting down at a desk and diligently examining the gold plates. We know that this isn’t how it happened. Emma Smith attests that the gold plates weren’t even in the room while other close testimonies say that they were occasionally in the room but were covered with a cloth. Either way, the portrayal that this picture gives us never happened.

These examples can be viewed as the LDS Church leaders being intentionally misleading and dishonest by allowing these pictures to be portrayed on their website, when they know full well that it is not the case.

Did the eyewitnesses of the risen Christ ever change their testimony?

They did not and that is one primary difference between the eyewitnesses of the risen Christ and the eyewitnesses of the gold plates. I encourage you to study and dig deeper the New Testament gospels of Jesus. I assure you that we can trust the words of Jesus and his apostles.

Please let me know your thoughts, things you appreciated or things that you disagreed with in the comment section below. Thank you for reading and God bless!

Geographic Evidence: The Bible vs The Book of Mormon

In one of my other posts, called “How Did We Get The Book Of Mormon?” (https://jllds.org/2023/12/21/how-did-we-get-the-book-of-mormon-pt-1/), I mentioned a discussion that I had with one of my missionary friends. After I gave him my answer, he responded and said, “How then do you go about explaining the geographic specifications that are mentioned in the BOM? Did Joseph Smith just happen to get super lucky in getting all of those things correct when he was on the other side of the world and talking about things that happened 2000+ years ago?”

In any case, both the BOM and Bible can’t be proven to be 100% true by evidence, especially in regard to the miracles and specific details of the stories within. But in regard to the people and tribes mentioned, and also in regard to the cities that are mentioned, those things can be legitimately proven! To give us a baseline, let’s start with a few of the archeological discoveries related to the Bible:

  1. The Tel Dan Stele: This ancient tablet dates back to roughly 800 BC. The phrase “house of David” is mentioned on it. This just goes to show that the Biblical writers weren’t fabricated this dynasty. The house of David that is referenced in the Old Testament is something that actually existed in history.

2. The Cyrus cylinder: King Cyrus of Persia wrote on this horizontal clay jar about how he allowed his slaves to return to home and rebuilt their sanctuaries for their gods. In Ezra chapter 1, we read about the same guy (king Cyrus) and it says that Cyrus allowed the Israelites to return to Jerusalem and rebuild their temple for Yahweh, the one true God. That’s external and secular archeology that directly supports a person, a place, a tribe and an event that is referenced in the Bible.

3. The Moabite Stone: This was written by the king of Moab. He writes about how the king of Israel oppressed them (the Moabites) for a long time. Then they eventually rebelled and conquered Israel. The Bible talks about this same event in 2 Kings 3:4-7. This is also important because here we have clear external evidence from an enemy of Israel which verifies that the nation of Israel and Moab were actual historical people groups in history and not just tribes that the Biblical writers fabricated.

4. In 2 Kings 20:20, we read about King Hezekiah and how he built a tunnel for a better water source when he was king of Israel. That tunnel has been discovered, confirmed and excavated.

5. The pool of Siloam is mentioned in John 9:7 when Jesus healed the blind man. That has been discovered as well!

6. The picture above (left side) is what Jericho used to look like: a heavily fortified city that was surrounded by an impenetrable wall. In the right picture, you’ll notice that the wall is divided into two sections: bricks on top and stones on the bottom.

This is what Jericho looks like today. Both secular and Christian scholars agree that this is the geographic location of Jericho. As you can see in the pictures above, the bottom section of the wall is still standing thousands of years later! When archeologists first discovered this location, they dug at the base of the stone wall only to find the crumbled remains of the bricks that were once standing on top of the stones. Again, both secular and Christian scholars agree that there was an outside tribe that laid siege against Jericho which is undoubtably what caused those mighty walls to come tumbling down…just as the Bible describes.

7. Many of the cities that are mentioned in the Bible are still on maps today.

8. Rivers and seas mentioned in the Bible are still on maps today: Sea of Galilee, the Dead sea, Jordan river, Red Sea, .

9. We read in Genesis that the Garden of Eden was near the Tigris and Euphrates Rivers. Those rivers still exist to this day in Africa.

10. All scholars agree that the disciples of Jesus were real people and that Paul was a historical person. Most, if not all the places that Paul visited on his missionary journeys have been confirmed by all historians to be real places as well. 

Now that we have some examples of what constitutes as legitimate geographic and archeological evidence, let’s pivot to the Book of Mormon and the archeological evidence that it has to offer. Dee Green and Thomas Ferguson were two of the earliest archeologists who worked for the department of archeology at BYU as faithful members of the LDS Church. After years of research, here is what Dee Green had to say on the matter:

“The first myth we need to eliminate is that Book of Mormon archaeology exists… If one is to study Book of Mormon archaeology, then one must have a corpus of data with which to deal. We do not… Biblical archaeology can be studied because we do know where Jerusalem and Jericho were and are, but we do not know where Zarahemla and Bountiful, nor any other location for that matter, were or are.” (A Journal of Mormon Thought, 1969. Pg 76-78)

Thomas Ferguson was also very dedicated to finding archeological evidence for the Book of Mormon. In the end, here is what he said:

“With all of these great efforts, it cannot be established factually that anyone has put his finger on a single point of terrain that was a Book-of-Mormon geographical place. And the hemisphere has been pretty well checked out by competent people. Thousands of sites have been excavated…Evidence of the foregoing animals has not appeared in any form — ceramic representations, bones or skeletal remains, mural art, sculptured art or any other form.  The zero score presents a problem that will not go away with the ignoring of it.  The absence of such evidence…is distressing and significant…I’m afraid that up to this point, I must agree with Dee Green, who has told us that to date there is no Book of Mormon geography. I, for one, would be happy if Dee were wrong.” (Written Symposium on Book-of-Mormon Geography, 1975, pg 4)

A year later, Fergeson proceeded with further details: “The real implication of the paper is that you can’t set Book of Mormon geography down anywhere–because it is fictional and will never meet the requirements of the dirt-archeology. I should say –what is in the ground will never conform to what is in the book.” (Letter to Mr. & Mrs. Lawrence, 1976)

A professor at BYU named Ray Matheny also stated:

“While some people choose to make claims for the Book of Mormon through archaeological evidences, to me they are made prematurely, and without sufficient knowledge…I would feel terribly embarrassed if anyone sent a copy of any book written on the subject (supporting archeology for the BOM) to the National Museum of Natural History – Smithsonian Institution, or other authority, making claims that cannot as yet be substantiated.…there are very severe problems in this field in trying to make correlations with the scriptures. Speculation, such as practiced so far by Mormon authors has not given church members credibility.” (Letter by Ray T. Matheny, dated Dec. 17, 1987)

Here are three faithful LDS members who have dedicated much of their live to discovering legitimate archeology for the Book of Mormon. But in their painful and honest admission, they both state that there is absolutely no archeological evidence that supports the existence of the people, cities, tribes and events listed therein. And these two men aren’t alone. This has happened to a number of Latter-Day Saints who set out on a sincere mission to prove the geography for the Book of Mormon. But then they end up realizing…there’s nothing. For many, it breaks their faith. Even current apologetic sources like Fair Latter Day Saint made this statement:

The Book of Mormon talks about the big battle between the Lamanites and the Nephites on the Hill Cumorah. The LDS Church has a visiting center today for the Hill Cumorah, which is located in Manchester, New York. (screenshot below)

There were allegedly millions of people who fought against each other during this last battle, yet no artifact, shield, sword, tablet, or verification of any kind has ever been discovered. But here is the kicker: we apparently “know” the general vicinity of where the battle of Hill Cumorah took place, right? The LDS Church confirmed this in the following letter:

“The Church has long maintained as attested to by references in the writings of general authorities, that the Hill Cumorah in western New York state is the same as referenced in the Book of Mormon (Ether 15:2).” (General Authority Michael Watson, 1990, Letter to Bishop Brooks)

If I was a Church leader, I would be searching every nook and cranny on that hill to prove to the world that the Book of Mormon is true. And guess what? This is exactly what the LDS Church did. After their search, they quietly released their findings:

“In accord with these general observations about New York and Pennsylvania, we come to our principal object—the Hill Cumorah. Archaeologically speaking, it is a clean hill. No artifacts, no walls, no trenches, no arrowheads. The area immediately surrounding the hill is similarly clean. Pre-Columbian people did not settle or build here. This is not the place of Mormon’s last stand. We must look elsewhere for that hill.” (BYU Publication – John E. Clark, “Archaeology and Cumorah Questions”, Journal of Book of Mormon Studies, Volume 13, Number 1, p.151 (July 31, 2004);

Much of this can be boiled down to this one critical thought:

Am I really supposed to believe that the same God inspired both of these books?

Is it wise for me to believe that God would really be that inconsistent and say, “My first book is going to have so much archeological evidence even atheists will be convinced of its validity and come to Christ (which there are many testimonies of)…while my 2nd book is going to have so little evidence that it’s going to cause many strong believers to lose their faith and walk away from my Church?”

I know that God isn’t asking us to know the answers to every single question in life, but he has given us a mind and he expects us to use it. One of the things I love most about Christianity is that it is the farthest thing from a blind faith. There are so many good reasons to trust the Bible to be a compilation of legitimate and historical documents with events that actually took place and people who actually lived! For evidence supporting that the Bible we have today is trustworthy and reliable, feel free to check my article: “Has The Bible Been Accurately Preserved Over Time.” https://jllds.org/2023/12/15/has-the-bible-been-accurately-preserved-over-time/

When it comes to these the Bible and the Book of Mormon, there is no competition for which one has more external and archeological support for his historicity and validity. Yet we see the Book of Mormon (1 Nephi 13:28) stating that many plain and precious truths have been removed from the book of the Lamb/Bible, implying that we can’t fully trust what it says because it has basically been tampered with and corrupted to an extent. Doesn’t it seem very much backwards that the book with little to no evidence is criticizing the book with overwhelming evidence?

I know it might sound ridiculous if you have been raised in the LDS Church your whole life…but if you are an LDS member, I want to invite you to entertain the idea and ponder this question:

If God was leading you out of the LDS Church, would you honestly be willing to follow him?

Please let me know your thoughts, things you appreciated or things that you disagreed with in the comment section below. Thank you for reading and God bless!

How Did We Get The Book Of Mormon

An LDS missionary friend of mine once asked me, “Paul, I got a question for you: Where do you believe the Book of Mormon came from?” To start, we know that Joseph Smith was the seer/translator while Oliver Cowdry, John Whitner and Emma Smith were the scribes. However, I believe that a fair and unbiased position for us to start at would be admitting that no one 100% knows where Joseph Smith got most of the Book of Mormon from. This is largely because no supporting manuscript or plate has ever been discovered, unlike the Bible which has over 26,000 manuscripts for the New Testament alone.

In any case, we can start by examining the source of the Book of Mormon. What do we know about Joseph Smith and his background? To start, we know that he was a poor farm boy and that his family was destitute. This is one factor that led both Joseph and his father into the business of treasure digging. Church history also tells us that Smith and his family were also into folk magic and occultic like practices. There are accounts of Smith and his dad killing dogs and sprinkling its’ blood to appease the spirits that were “guarding the buried treasure” in hopes that the spirit would allow them to take the treasure. Below are a few quotes from LDS history on the matter:

  • “The facts are that the sacrifice of white dogs, black sluts, black cats, and such like was an indispensable part or appendage of the art which Smith, the embryo prophet, was then practicing.” (Early Mormon Documents, Dan Vogel, 4:308-309)
  • “For in the time of their digging for money and not finding it attainable, Joe Smith told them there was a charm on the pots of money, and if some animal was killed and the blood sprinkled around the place, then they could get it. So they killed a dog and tried this method of obtaining the precious metal; Still, they dug and dug, but never came to the precious treasure.” (Life Among the Mormons, Emily M Austin, 1882).

When Smith found a seer stone, it was right up his ally. He would then convince others that he was a seer and charge them money in exchange for him using his seer stone to help them find the buried treasure.

He would tell his customers where to dig, and after digging all around that area for a very long time, Smith would then look into his hat again to verify where the treasure was located. But there was a problem: As he lifted his head from the hat, he would say something along the lines of, “Sorry guys. The spirit caused the treasure to sink deeper into the earth…but we were so close!” Smith was never able to come through and find any treasure for any of his paying customers. Below are a few quotes on this:

  • “On accounting of an enchantment, the trunk (treasure) kept settling away from under them while digging.” (Docket Entry from a court hearing, 1826)
  • “He (Isaiah Stowell) positively knew that the prisoner (Joseph Smith) could tell, and professed the art of seeing those valuable treasures through the medium of said stone…that said Stowell and prisoner thereupon commenced digging, found a tail-feather, but money was gone; that he supposed that money moved down (sank into the earth);” (Miss Pearsall’s account of Josiah Stowell’s statement)

This question must be considered:

  • If Smith was poor and if he had a magic seer stone that truly could guide him to find the buried treasure…why wouldn’t he just go and dig up the treasure for him and his family?

    Moving on, Smith eventually met Emma. Smith asked Emma’s dad for his daughter’s hand in marriage. Emma’s dad believed that Smith was a con man. He did not approve of Smith’s treasure digging business and believed that he was intentionally fooling people into giving him their money. But Joseph and Emma eloped and got married anyways. After this happens, Smith returns and is in the process of moving Emma’s things from her parent’s house. Joseph Smith hired a young man named, Peter Ingersoll to help him move the furniture and records a conversation that took place between Joseph and Emma’s father.

    READ THIS VERY CLOSELY!

    • “In the month of August, 1827, I was hired by Joseph Smith, Jr. to go to Pennsylvania, to move his wife’s household furniture up to Manchester, where his wife then was. When we arrived at Mr. Hale’s, in Harmony, Pa. from which place he had taken his wife, a scene presented itself, truly affecting. His father-in-law [Emma’s dad] addressed Joseph, in a flood of tears: “You have stolen my daughter and married her. I had much rather have followed her to her grave. You spend your time in digging for money – pretend to see in a stone, and thus try to deceive people.” Joseph wept, and acknowledged he could not see in a stone now, nor never could; and that his former pretensions in that respect, were all false. He then promised to give up his old habits of digging for money and looking into stones.” (Peter Ingersoll, 1833)

    To summarize: Emma’s dad calls Smith out for scamming people and pretending to be able to use the seer stone, and then Smith admits to it. That he had been deceiving people and pretending to use a seer stone but was never actually able to use it.

    ______________________________________________________

    With this background in mind, we can now pivot and move on to the translation of the Book of Mormon. Smith claims that an angel Moroni appeared to him. Moroni told him where the gold plates are buried. Smith goes to the hill Cumorah to get the gold plates but Moroni would not allow Smith to take the gold plates yet. Think of the parallel here:

    • Instead of treasure being guarded by spirits, Smith is now telling us that there are gold plates that are being guarded by an angel. A skeptic might connect the dots and say, “Well, it looks like Smith just took the scenario from treasure digging and repackaged it in a religious wrapping.”

    After Smith received the gold plates, he translated the Book of Mormon then Moroni took the gold plates up to heaven without a trace. Yet another parallel with treasure digging: First, we have guardian spirits that could move the treasure so that it can’t be found, and now we have an angel taking the gold plates so that they can’t be found.

    When translating the Book of Mormon, Smith didn’t even look at the gold plates. Once again, he used the same seer stone in the hat. The biggest concern here is this: if Smith previously admitted to being a fraud, is it wise for us to trust that now all of the sudden, Smith can accurately and divinely use this same seer stone when it failed to find him any treasure before? If he deceived people and pretended to have the ability to use the seer before, what reason do we have to trust him now?

    In connection to Smith being poor and destitute: his business associate, Martin Harris, sold his farm to publish the Book of Mormon. Here we have two primary people who are highly motivated by finances for this religious book to succeed. Just after writing the BOM in 1830, Smith even tried to sell the copy wright in Canada but was unsuccessful. On this matter, former BYU professor Marvin Hill writes:

    • “The economic situation of the Smith families was so desperate at this time that Joseph tried to sell the copyright of the Book of Mormon…Page indicated that they hoped to get $8,000 (equivalent to $272,500 today) for the copyright and that they traveled to Canada covertly to prevent Martin Harris from sharing in the dividend. Smith evidently believed that Harris was well enough off while his own family was destitute.”

    Then the last thing I have to touch on is how this story of how Smith translating the BOM was portrayed to LDS members before the internet and also how it is still being portrayed to investigators today. LDS missionaries have a set of pamphlets that they hand out to people. One of them is called “The Restoration of the gospel of Jesus Christ.” It briefly talks about Smith translating the BOM and says, “By the power of God, Joseph Smith translated this book from an ancient record written on gold plates.” In people’s minds, this naturally leads them to picture Smith sitting at a desk while diligently studying and translating the gold plates.

    This picture above is currently on the Church website today. The name of the article is: “Joseph Smith Translates the Gold Plates.” However, Emma Smith specifically stated that the gold plates weren’t even in the same room when Smith was translating the BOM. This picture never happened. The LDS Church leaders never publicly came clean to their members by stating that Smith used a seer stone in a hat until after 2010. The seer stone and the hat are very often omitted by missionaries unless the investigator brings it up.

    I once asked a missionary, “How did Smith translate the Book of Mormon?” He responded by asking, “What do you know about it?” The thought entered my mind, “Does the way you answer my question depend on what I am aware of?” I was honest with him and said that I know about the seer stone and the hat, but if I was someone who hadn’t done any research on the topic, would he have mentioned the seer stone at all? I don’t know the answer to that question, but I do know that if investigators were aware of how this translation process accurately took place, then that would significantly decrease the number of converts to the LDS Church…and the LDS Church leaders obviously don’t want that to happen.

    This brings us back to my beginning point: we can’t say for sure where Smith might have gotten his ideas from. He might not have been super intellectual or formally educated, but he could have been very street savvy. The evidence for this lies in the fact that he was able to fool people into believing that he was a real seer who could find treasure. It takes people skills and charisma to have the ability to convince people that you are the real deal when you are truly a fraud.

    While we can’t say for sure where Smith got most of the BOM from, we do know for sure where he got some of it from: the King James Bible. Specifically, chapters from Isaiah that are recorded in 2 Nephi. In the King James Bible, there are a couple verses in these chapters where the translators mistranslated a word.

    Example: Isaiah 2:16 “And upon all the ships of Tarshish, and upon all pleasant pictures.”

    The misinterpreted word at the end is “pictures,” but it should be “ships.” There are some other unique errors like this that are only found in the King James Bible. We know that Joseph Smith took these passages right out of the King James Bible and pasted them into the Book of Mormon because the 1830 version of the Book of Mormon had these exact same errors. The Book of Mormon has had over 3,000 changes since it was published in 1830. In the current 2013 edition, those errors have been fixed. But if God truly gave Smith those gold plates, and if Smith truly had the gift of translating them, it would seem to make sense that those identical errors wouldn’t be there in the BOM.

    There allegedly were 11 eyewitnesses (the 3 and the 8) who saw the gold plates. To learn more about this claim, check out the article: “The 3 Witnesses: Can We Trust Their Testimonies?” (https://jllds.org/2024/04/19/the-3-witnesses-can-we-trust-their-testimonies-2/)

    Instead of asking, “Where did the Book of Mormon come from?” I think a better question we should ask is this:

    • Is it wise for me to trust that what Joseph Smith has presented was truly from God? Or was it another scam?

    I encourage you to put for trust in the Word of God, and not in the words of men claiming to speak on behalf of God. Thank you for reading, God bless and remember to never stop chasing after Jesus!

    BOM Intro Page & DNA

    In 2005 and all years prior, the BOM Introduction page read, “all were destroyed except the Lamanites, and they are the principal ancestors of the American Indians.”  But if you look in your Book of Mormon starting in 2006 and onward, it now reads: “all were destroyed except the Lamanites, and they are among the ancestors of the American Indians.”

    So let that just sink in for a minute. That introduction page originally read that “the Lamanites are the principal ancestors of the American Indians” and then for some reason in 2006, the LDS Church decided to slightly change the wording to, “The Lamanites are AMONG the ancestors of the American Indians.” If I was a Latter Day Saint shoes, I would be curious enough to ask the questions:

    1. Why did they make that change?
    2. And why did they choose to make this change in 2006?

    I think the timing of this change is important because if we understand the recent events that led up to this change, I think it can help shed light on why the change may have occurred.

    Leading up to this change, people tested the DNA of the Indians and Mayans. The LDS Church was eager about this as they were seeking for evidence to demonstrate that the Book of Mormon was legitimate history. If they could prove that Native Americans genetically originated from the middle east, that would be a tremendous help to their cause.

    However, the DNA test results showed that the vast majority, if not all of the Native Americans migrated from Southeast Asia. To say this more clearly, it’s been proven virtually by all DNA analysis experts that the Indians did not come from the Middle East as the Book of Mormon and LDS Church leaders have taught over the years.

    The LDS Church acknowledged this and that is what led to that slight change on this introduction page. They know that their previous wording of the Lamanites being “the principal ancestors of the American Indians” is false. So they had to change it so that it now it reads that the Lamanites are “AMONG the ancestors of the American Indian.”

    Does the truth matter to you personally? If so, are you willing to follow the evidence wherever it leads? For more information on evidence, check out my article called, “Geographic Evidence: The BOM vs The Bible.”

    Please let me know your thoughts, things you appreciated or things that you disagreed with in the comment section below. Thank you for reading and God bless!

    The Mission

    There are 3 primary goals for this ministry website.

    #1 – Whenever I engage people of different faiths, it is always for 3 reasons:
        A.  Love for God
        B.  Love for others
        C.  Love for the truth
    Galatians 1:6-7 “I am astonished that you are so quickly deserting the one who called you to live in the grace of Christ and are turning to a different gospel— which is really no gospel at all. Evidently some people are throwing you into confusion and are trying to pervert the gospel of Christ.”
       - Jesus has given us his amazing gospel of grace. There are sadly many people
        who are under a false gospel of works and a false gospel cannot save anyone.
        My desire is to equip the saints and build them up so that they can
        clearly proclaim the true gospel of grace to their LDS friends, family members and
        missionaries and to contend for the faith that was once and for all delivered to
        the church of Christ (Jude 1:3).

    #2 – I have discovered that there are a number of Bible based Christians who are interested in having theological discussions with Latter-Day Saints but are either unsure how to go about starting this kind of conversation or all they want to do is argue with and “bash” them. I used to be one of those people who just wanted to prove that the LDS Church is false. God has worked on my heart a lot over the years. He has replaced my heart of contention with a heart of love and compassion for my LDS friends and missionaries who come to my door. I hope to inspire other Bible-based Christians to approach missionaries with this same kind of love and respect that I have found to be so much more fruitful and enjoyable.

    #3 – In the Fall of 2023, I had 3 missionaries over who helped me rake leaves as a service project. Afterwards, I bought them lunch and we ate in my downstairs living room while talking about some essential topics. We focused primarily on what it means to have a personal relationship with Jesus and also how we can become declared 100% righteous before God. As I was taking them through a number of Bible different passages, one of the elders said, “Thank you for creating this kind of atmosphere where we can study the Bible together.” And that is my sincere hope: to teach both Bible-based Christians and Latter-Day Saints how to contextually and honestly interpret the Word of God. If you are someone who is desiring to gain a better understanding of the teachings of Jesus and his apostles, this is the place for you. Just click on one of the “related” links below or go to the ” Resources” menu above, click on “Bible Lessons,” then select a lesson that is of interest to you and get started!

    What Did Joseph Smith Add To The Bible?

    After Joseph Smith published the Book of Mormon in March 1830, he began the new task of retranslating the Bible just three months later in June. The Book of Mormon implies that this was a much-needed task as it says in 1 Nephi 13:26:

    Then two verses later in 1 Nephi 13:28, we read:

    “Wherefore, thou seest that AFTER the book hath gone forth through the hands of the great and abominable church, that there are many plain and precious things taken away from the book, which is the book of the Lamb of God.”

    To clarify: the Book of the Lamb is the Bible. This verse sets up the stage very nicely for Joseph to save the day and restore to the Bible all the “plain and precious things” that were removed from it during the Great Apostasy, which the LDS Church claims to have happened after the time of Christ.

    Here is the good news: we have Biblical manuscripts that were written BEFORE the great apostasy allegedly occurred! In 1947, there was the monumental discovery of the Dead Sea scrolls. They are a collection of Jewish writings that primarily consist of Old Testament fragments. Included on these scrolls are chapters from Genesis, Psalms, Deuteronomy, Leviticus, Job and many other books. The most impactful discovery was the Great Isaiah scroll. This scroll is important and unique because it contains all 66 chapters of Isaiah. Scholars have dated this scroll to have been written around 125 BC.

    Prior to this discovery, the most ancient manuscript of Isaiah we had was written around 800 AD, which is referred to as the Masoretic text. If we do the math, we can conclude that the Great Isaiah scroll was written approximately 900 years earlier than the Masoretic text. Surely, the scribes would have changed, added and removed important doctrines during that gap in time. Researchers examined both the Dead Sea Scroll of Isaiah with the Masoretic text to identify every difference between the two in order to see what all had been changed over time. After comparing them, both Christian and secular scholars alike have concluded that the messages and doctrines contained in these two documents are identical. While there might be minor differences in spelling and grammar, not a single doctrine was been added or removed.

    “Even though the two copies of Isaiah discovered in Qumran Cave 1 near the Dead Sea in 1947 were a thousand years earlier than the oldest dated manuscript previously known (A.D. 980), they proved to be word for word identical with our standard Hebrew Bible in more than 95 percent of the text. The five percent of variation consisted chiefly of obvious slips of the pen and variations in spelling.” -Gleason Archer (Biblical scholar, theologian, professor and author)

    At the very least, both Bible Based Christians and Latter-Day Saints can agree on the fact that the Book of Isaiah in our Bibles today has been accurately preserved over time. It’s important remember the fact that the Great Isaish scroll was written BEFORE the Book of the Lamb went through the great and abominable church as the Book of Mormon claims. Keeping this in mind, there is no reason to believe that Book of Isaiah had “many plain and precious truths” removed from it before the Great Apostasy. We have every reason to confidently belief that the messages and doctrines found in the book of Isaiah are the exact same as when it was first penned.

    _____________________________________________________________________________________

    “Paul…what does the Book of Isaiah have to do with Joseph Smith?”

    I’m glad you asked! Let’s start with some of the changes that Joseph Smith made to the Bible, starting with the book of Isaiah. A while ago, I came across a very useful study tool related to this topic. It is a JST (Joseph Smith Translation) and KJV (King James Version) Parallel Bible. It only lists Bible passages that Joseph Smith changed. On each page, there is the JST on one half of the page and the KJV on the other side. This way, you can see for yourself exactly what Joseph Smith changed, added and removed.

    Below is the first change that we will discuss which occurs in Isaiah chapter 29, starting at verse 11. My personal handwritten notes are included in the screenshots (please excuse the sloppiness of my handwriting):

    There are two primary observations we can make regarding these changes and additions:

    1. As previously established, the evidence shows that the messages and doctrines in the book of Isaiah have not changed over time. Why then did Joseph add these LDS doctrines into Isaiah 29? And notice that it’s not just minor changes or a few added verses here and there. He is literally adding paragraphs into this chapter. Despite the evidence that we have already established, are we really supposed to believe that Isaiah 29 really had all of these passages removed from it?
    2. Notice the green highlighted parts in the JST above. Do you see how they are prophecies specifically related to himself, the book of Mormon and the 3 witnesses to the book of Mormon? It would seem as if Joseph Smith is attempting to smuggle prophecies about his own religion into the Bible.

    ________________________________________________________________________________________________________

    These aren’t the only prophecies Joseph added into the Bible. There is also a particular passage is found in Genesis 50:33. Note that every single Bible that has ever existed has 50 chapters in Genesis. Likewise, every single Bible in Genesis 50 only has 26 verses…except for one. Yes, Genesis 50 in the JST has 38 verses as Smith felt justified in adding an extra 12 verses to this chapter. What do these verses consist of and why did Joseph feel the need to add them to God’s Word?

    This added verse is telling us that God is going to bring forth a seer at some point in the future. His name will be Joseph and his dad’s name will also be Joseph. He is also going bring salvation to people. We saw this same tactic in Isaiah 29, and we are seeing it again now as Joseph Smith is adding another prophecy about himself into the Bible without any justification.

    There were some Bible verses that were in opposition to Smith’s theological beliefs. Instead of changing his beliefs to match up with God’s Word, he decides to change God’s Word to make it match up with his beliefs. He accomplishes this by simply adding the word “not” into 2 Samuel 12:13 & Romans 4:5:

    Smith was motivated to change other passages in order to protect himself. Exodus 22:18 condemned those who practice witchcraft and sorcery to death. However, Smith was one who practiced witchcraft and sorcery. How does he solve this problem? By simply changing the word “witch” to “murderer.”

    KJV: “Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live.”
    JST: “Thou shalt not suffer a murderer to live.”

    Genesis 14 is another important passage to cover:

    The right side of the page is blank because none of what Smith added is in the KJV nor is it in any manuscript that has ever been discovered. This is another example of Joseph Smith added paragraphs into God’s Word. We also see that the things he chooses to insert are foundational LDS doctrines such as the structure of priesthood authority being passed on through ordinances. The paragraphs that Smith inserts are specifically regarding this doctrine. He knows that these things are contextually absent from the Bible. Therefore, he feels the need to add them into the Bible. He does this same tactic with 1 Corinthians 15:40 by adding the word “telestial” into the verse:

    Joseph Smith wants it to be abundantly clear that this verse is talking about the 3 kingdoms of heaven as taught by the LDS Church. I’ve also included a clip from the Interlinear Greek for further clarification as to what the correct words in this passage are. There is no Greek word for “telestial.” It was never written in Paul’s letter to the Corinthians. Smith simply dictated to add this word into the verse.

    This next one is intriguing. We know that there are a number of passages from the KJV that are also in the BOM. An example of this is Matthew 7:23. In the KJV, this verse reads, “I never knew you.” In the BOM in 3 Nephi 14:23, it says the same thing, “I never knew you.” Yet in the JST, Smith changed this verse and to make it say, “You never knew me.”

    This creates the dilemma of: which one is right? Joseph Smith’s translation of the Bible or Joseph Smith’s translation of the Book of Mormon? They were both translated by the same person about Jesus giving the same message, yet they both say different things!

    I believe that John 1:1 is also worth noting as Joseph completely changes the meaning the verse as well as the person of Jesus in his translation:

    ________________________________________________________________________________________________________

    Examining these differences is important so that we can see for ourselves what exactly Joseph Smith changed in his translation of the Bible. It has always struck me as odd that the majority of LDS Church members carry a KJV much more often than a JST. If they truly believe that Smith divinely translated the Bible, why don’t they all use the JST? My personal opinion is that the JST is far too different than any standard Bible that has ever been written. When compared to any other Bible, the JST sticks out like a sore thumb because of how clearly intentional Joseph Smith was about inserting prophecies of the BOM, prophecies about himself, and doctrines of the LDS Church into God’s Word.

    If someone is trying to insert something into God’s Word that was never there to begin with, that leaves us with the conclusion that they are actively and knowingly attempting to corrupt the very Word of God to make it match up with their personal believers. We see the Jehovah’s Witnesses do this exact same thing with their New World Translation. At the end of the day, we must honestly ask ourselves the question:

    Would a true prophet of God intentionally corrupt His Word?

    Thank you for reading and God bless!

    Polygamy & Polyandry

    Plural Marriage has always been a topic that has been attacked by many people outside of the LDS Church. From a certain perspective, one has be careful before casting the first stone. After all, Abraham, Jacob, and David engaged in plural marriage, didn’t they? For clarification, I am not justifying the actions of anyone in the Old Testament and I do not believe the plural marriage was ever commanded by God. If anyone can show me a verse of God commanding someone in the Bible to take an additional wife, I will gladly change my perspective. No one has succeeded so far.

    That being said, the issue isn’t just the fact that Smith had over 30 wives. A deeper part of the issue stems from how the situations of these additional brides occurred. To help see things more clearly, it sometimes helps to put these things in a chronological order. So let’s start by doing that. And these things that I am listing have all been verified by LDS historians and admitted to by the LDS Church. Screenshots from the LDS Church website immediately follow:

    1. Joseph Smith marries Emma (1827)
    2. Smith writes the Book of Mormon. In Jacob 2:24, polygamy is an abomination to God. (1830)
    3. Joseph and Emma have a 17-year-old house maid Fanny Alger who was living with them, named Fanny Alger. Smith marries Fanny without Emma’s knowledge. (1835)
    4. Smith gets married and sealed to additional women without Emma’s knowledge. (1841 -1843) (screenshot below)
    5. Smith finally gets sealed to Emma (May 28th, 1843). Although she was the first wife he was married to, Joseph was sealed to 20 women prior to being sealed to Emma. I can’t help but ask the question, “If Smith was truly a faithful husband and man of God, why wasn’t Emma the 1st wife Smith was sealed to? And why did Smith marry other women behind Emma’s back?” (screenshot below)
    6. Smith then receives a revelation that conflicts with what he wrote in the Book of Mormon, Jacob 2:24. His new revelation is D&C 132 which states that Polygamy is now part of God’s everlasting covenant. (July 12th, 1843)
    7. Smith continues to get married and sealed to 10+ more wives, 30-40 in all:
    • 3 pairs of sisters (Partridges, Johnsons, Lawrences – Leviticus 18:18)
    • 1 pair of mother-daughter (Patty Bartlett Sessions & Sylvia Sessions Lyon – Leviticus 18:17)
    • His youngest wife was 14 years old.
    • 11 of his wives had living husbands when he married them. This is called, polyandry. No prophet before Smith ever practiced polyandry. (screenshot below)

    One would think that Smith should have received this revelation (D&C 132) prior to marrying all of these other wives without Emma’s knowledge rather than conveniently receiving the revelation after the fact. Some of you might be thinking, “Paul, take it easy on Joseph Smith. He wasn’t in it for the sex. He was focused on keeping families together in the afterlife and being sealed for eternity.”

    To this response, the question must be asked, “If Smith truly was focused on sealings and keeping families together in the afterlife, why is it that he was never sealed to his own parents or children? Why were women the only people he only got sealed to?”

    ________________________________________________________

    One thing that does not sit well with others is the fact that Joseph Smith hid a number of these marriages from Emma.

    Joseph Smith married Fanny Alger without telling Emma. When Emma discovered this, she was furious, and drove Fanny out of her house.

    Not only did Joseph hide a number of his marriages from Emma. He also publicly lied about it as well:

    • ”What a thing it is for a man to be accused of committing adultery, and having seven wives, when I can only find one. I am the same man, and as innocent as I was fourteen years ago; and I can prove them all perjurers.” (History of the Church, vol 6, p. 411) May, 1844

    At this time, Smith had over 25 wives.

    On June 7th, 1844, the Navoo Printing Press was able to only published one issue. It primarily focused on exposing Joseph Smith and his secret practices of polygamy after he publicly denied engaging in the practice just two months prior. In the Navoo Expositors first and only publication, there are 2 affidavits that speak of Smith’s push towards polyandry (1 woman being married to 2 men). William Law was in the first presidency and a big leader next to Joseph Smith. Both he and his wife (Jane Law) came forward and stated that Joseph Smith made advances towards Jane and asked her to be one of his polyandrous wives. Both William and Jane detested this idea and believed that Joseph Smith had gone too far and wanted to raise awareness of these secrets by putting in the newspaper that was printed by the Navoo Expositor. On June 10th, Joseph Smith being the mayor, ordered for the Navoo Printing Press to be destroyed. Even though Smith was the mayor, this action was against the law. As a result, Joseph Smith and his brother Hyrum were arrested and taken to Carthage jail.

    There were other times when he would approach younger women with a bribe by promising them exaltation not only for themselves but for their parents as well. Then other times, Smith would threaten them, saying that an angel with a flaming sword would kill him if they did not agree to marry him. For Lucy Walker (17), she testifies:

    “In the year 1842, President Joseph Smith sought an interview with me, and said: “I have a message for you. I have been commanded of God to take another wife, and you are the woman.” My astonishment knew no bounds. This announcement was indeed a thunderbolt to me… Gross darkness instead of light took possession of my mind. I was tempted and tortured beyond endurance until life was not desirable… He saw how unhappy I was, and later sought an opportunity of again speaking to me on this subject, and said: “It is a command of God to you. I will give you until tomorrow to decide this matter. If you reject this message the gate will be closed forever against you.”

    The part that makes me most upset is process of how terrible Lucy felt when Smith initially asked her to marry him. She doesn’t give him an answer, then Smith later approaches Lucy again and then decides to pressure her into saying, “Yes” to his marriage proposal. All of this occurred while Lucy’s father was away on his mission and Smith insisted that Lucy and her siblings move into his own house.

    From an honest and unbiased perspective, what are we to make of Smith in this situation with Lucy?

    ___________________________________________________________________

    Some choose not to believe that Smith ever married other women who were already married. That it is a lie that he practiced polyandry. Again, the official LDS Church website agrees that these things are in fact true:

    There were 11 women that we know of that Joseph Smith was sealed to who all had living husbands. We know that at least some of the husbands were faithful latter day saints as well. Why not encourage these women to be sealed to their current husband?

    Diaries of Joseph Smith. April 1842. “Verily thus saith the Lord unto you my servant Joseph, that inasmuch as you have called upon me to know my will concerning my handmaid Nancy Marinda Hyde—behold it is my will that she should have a better place prepared for her, than that in which she now lives, in order that her life may be spared unto her; therefore go and say unto my servant, Ebenezer Robinson, and to my handmaid his wife—Let them open their doors and take her and her children into their house and take care of them faithfully and kindly unto my servant Orson Hyde returns from his mission, or until some other provision can be made for her welfare and safety.”

    • Joseph Smith send Orson Hyde on a mission. While he is away preaching the restored gospel, Smith decides to get married and sealed to Orson’s wife. Upon returning and discovering this, accounts describe Hyde understandably being “in a furious passion.” Why didn’t Smith just let Orson get sealed to his wife for eternity once he returned from his mission? Why would he jump the gun like that?
    • Why can’t Joseph Smith provide a better place for these women without getting sealed to them?

    _____________________________________________________________________

    Some respond to this by saying, “The marriage was just a sealing ritual. Smith never had sex with any of those other women. He was always faithful to Emma.” The official Church website says otherwise:

    Below are statements made by the wives of Joseph Smith:

    Emily Partridge (19 years old) – When under oath in a deposition in the Temple Lot case, Emily Partridge was asked, “Do you make the declaration that you ever slept with him (Joseph Smith) in the same bed?” to which she answered, “Yes sir.”

    Lucy Walker (17 years old) – Lucy’s niece, Theodocia Frances Walker Davis, reported to Joseph Smith III in 1876, “Lucy Walker told her that she lived with Joseph Smith as a wife.”

    Malissa Lott (19 years old) – In an 1893 interview, Malissa Lott was asked if she was the Prophet’s “wife in very deed,” to which she answered, “Yes.” Implying sexual relations as between a typical husband and wife.

    Eliza Partridge (22 years old) – Benjamin F. Johnson wrote in 1903: “The first plural wife brought to my house with whom the Prophet stayed, was Eliza Partridge.”

    Louisa Beaman (26 years old) – When Joseph Bates Noble, Louisa’s brother-in-law, was asked: “Where did they [Joseph Smith and plural wife Louisa Beaman] sleep together?” He responded: “Right straight across the river at my house they slept together.”

    Almera Johnson (29 years old) – Almera’s brother, Benjamin Johnson said, “He [Joseph Smith] was at my house … where he occupied my sister Almera’s room and bed.”

    Sarah Lawrence – Lucy Walker (one of Smith’s wives) attested in 1902: “I know that [Emma] gave her consent to the marriage of at least four women [Emily and Eliza Partridge and Maria (19) and Sarah Lawrence (16)] to her husband as plural wives, and she was well aware that he associated and cohabited with them as wives.”

    _____________________________________________________________________

    Saints, Volume 1 – The Standard of Truth; Ch. 40, pg 490 “Because neither Joseph nor Emma wrote down how they felt about plural marriage, many questions are left unanswered. In her writings, Emily (Partridge) recorded some of their struggles with the practice. At times Emma rejected it completely while at other times reluctantly accepting it as a commandment. Torn between the Lord’s mandate to practice plural marriage and Emma’s opposition, Joseph sometimes chose to marry women without Emma’s knowledge, creating distressing situations for everyone involved.

    In early May, Emma took Emily and Eliza aside and explained the principle of plural marriage to them. She had told Joseph that she would consent to him being sealed to two additional wives as long as she could choose them, and she had chosen Emily and Eliza, apparently unaware that Joseph had already been sealed to them.

    Rather than mention her former sealing, Emily believed that keeping silent on the matter was the best thing for her to do. A few days later, she and Eliza were again sealed to Joseph, this time with Emma as a witness.”

    • Just to make sure we understand this situation: Joseph Smith already married the Partridge sisters without Emma’s knowledge. Then later, Emma consented that Joseph could marry them. Instead of confessing to Emma and saying, “Hey, we actually already got sealed. Please forgive me.” Smith gets sealed to the sisters a second time without telling Emma so that she would think that this was the first time Smith was getting sealed to them to prevent her from getting angry.

    I believe that there is plenty of good evidence to believe that the Bible is true, the Jesus rose from the dead, and that He is the savior of the world. But when we step back, take an honest look at all of these historical factors about Joseph Smith, what is more reasonable for me to believe:

    That Smith was a true prophet of God?

    Or

    That he deceived people?

    You may find yourself losing faith in Jospeh Smith, the Book of Mormon, or the LDS Church…but never lose faith in Jesus. We can trust the words of the Savior that are found in the New Testament gospels. If you have ever asked yourself the question: Can I trust the Bible? Hasn’t it been corrupted over the years? Please check out my Bible Lesson called, “Has The Bible Been Accurately Preserved Over Time?”

    Please let me know your thoughts, things you appreciated or things that you disagreed with in the comment section below. Thank you for reading and God bless!

    The Book Of Abraham Controversy

    This topic is one of the most common reasons Ex-Mormons will give for why they lost faith in Joseph Smith and the LDS Church. Why does this topic stick out more than the others? I will provide the background summary and if you wish to dig further into the details directly from the LDS Church gospel topics essays, you can do so by clicking on this link: https://www.churchofjesuschrist.org/study/manual/gospel-topics-essays/translation-and-historicity-of-the-book-of-abraham?lang=eng

    • Joseph Smith purchased an Egyptian scroll from a man named Michael Chandler in 1835.
    • After Smith translated it, he described the scroll as: “the writings of Abraham, while he was in Egypt, called the Book of Abraham, written by his own hand, upon papyrus.”
    • It is important to note that at this time, scholars were still trying to figure out how to translate Egyptian into English. This gave Smith to liberty to make the scroll say whatever he would like and no one could prove him wrong.
    • Smith eventually sold the Egyptian papyri after translating it. It was believed that most of the papyri was destroyed during the Chicago fire in 1871. But lo and behold, ten papyrus fragments once in Joseph Smith’s possession ended up in the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City. They were purchased back by the LDS Church in 1967.
    • By this time, the discovery of the Rosetta stone occurred and this enabled scholars to crack the code to translate Egyptian into English. The LDS Church was excited to have Egyptologists translated the Book of Abraham. After all, if they could prove that Smith accurately translated the papyri, this would be undeniable proof that he was indeed a prophet of God.
    • After the Egyptologists translated the scroll that was supposedly written by the very hand of Abraham, they concluded that Smith didn’t accurately translated a single character, Abraham was not mentioned anywhere, the scroll dates to about 300 BC (far after the time of Abraham), and it was actually instructions for a pagan funeral.
    • The LDS Church acknowledges all of these things and are now forced to take the extremely biased explanation of: “Even though this document doesn’t literally say anything about Abraham and Smith didn’t literally “translate” it…God still used it to give Joseph Smith a revelation of the life of Abraham.” This is the position that is the LDS Church puts forth in the gospel topics essays.

    ___________________________________________________________________________________

    Below is part of what the recovered papyrus looked like and as you can see there are some missing fragments. This particular picture is known as “Facsimile #1” in the Book of Abraham. A facsimile is another word for picture or copy:

    Another common explanation for Smith’s translation might be: “Paul, the Book of Abraham was a long scroll. Yes, we now have part of that scroll, but we don’t have all of it. The part that we have now, doesn’t match the Book of Abraham but that doesn’t matter because those parts are NOT what Smith translated. All of the parts that Joseph Smith translated are missing.” First Smith translates the gold plates and those go missing. Now Smith translates the Egyptian papyri and all of the parts he translated go missing as well…convenient.

    This explanation is sometimes referred to as “the missing papyri” theory. I’m not going to spend time debating that point because it’s an argument from silence and even if it was the case, it honestly does not much change the situation at hand.

    Instead, we can analyze the facsimiles for ourselves and see where it takes us. Let’s start with Facsimile #1. As previously mentioned, this picture had some missing fragments. This meant that God had to give Jospeh Smith divine powers and knowledge to sketch in the missing parts and complete the picture so that he could “translate” the Book of Abraham:

    Scholars know that the picture on the right is a correct representation of the entire facsimile because they’ve discovered many other pagan funeral instructions in Egypt that are identical to facsimile. They all look like the picture on the right. Joseph Smith also listed the explanation/translation of the facsimile. You’ll notice that there are numbers on Joseph Smith’s facsimile. He goes through and tells us what each numbered figure is translated as. Let’s compare what Joseph Smith said against what the Egyptologists said:

    As you can see, not a single character was translated correctly and Abraham has nothing to do with this picture. Below is facsimile #2 and under it are the explanations/translations of Joseph Smith vs Egyptologist:

    Notice figures 9-21 specifically on Smith’s translation. I would say that Smith was very wise in his approach by leaving unfilled revelations in his back pocket in case anything went sideways and he needed a “quick revelation.” Anyhow, this one is another swing and a miss by Smith. Let’s see how close he got on Facsimile #3:

    _____________________________________________________________________________________

    And that is strike 3. As we can see for ourselves, Joseph Smith was nowhere close to accurately translating these facsimiles. The proof is right there in plain sight for anyone that has eyes to see. The reason why so many LDS members have left over this topic is because of how clearly this demonstrates that Smith was a fraud.

    Please know that I don’t say these things with any kind of pleasure. I sincerely encourage you not to follow men on earth who claim to be modern day prophets and apostles. We need to be wise and remember what Jesus said would happen in the last days:

    Matthew 24:11 “many false prophets will appear and deceive many people.”

    Today, there are indeed many false religions where people claim to be prophets and to have authority. I also beg you not to make the mistake of fully committing yourself to a church and thinking that this is the same thing as having a personal relationship with Jesus. Although those two things might be related, they are not the same thing.

    Don’t allow yourself to be misled by modern-day “prophets” who have said, “God told me to tell you this…” Instead, remove the men and women of this world who are standing between you and God. Follow Jesus by trusting in the words that He directly spoke which are found in the New Testament. There is always hope and redemption in Christ! To learn more about having a personal relationship with Jesus, check out my article: Who Is Your Personal Mediator (https://jllds.org/2023/12/13/who-is-your-personal-mediator/)

    Please let me know your thoughts, things you appreciated or things that you disagreed with in the comment section below. Thank you for reading and never stop chasing after Jesus!

    Race & The Priesthood

    One of the most common attacks against the LDS Church is the historic issue of racism. Some are content throwing 2nd President Brigham Young under the bus and blaming his “human side” for this great doctrinal error. However, we can see that Brigham Young is only one of many former Church leaders who approved and taught this doctrine:

    To many, this is an automatic blatant red flag. The good news is that eventually in 1978, the LDS Church decided to change this doctrine so that blacks could receive the priesthood, receive their temple endowment and be sealed to their spouse in the temple. While this is a step in the positive direction, they unfortunately are still stuck with the doctrines that branched into the prohibitions of blacks.

    “There is a reason why one man is born black and with other disadvantages, while another is born white with great advantages. The reason is that we once had an estate before we come here, and were obedient, more or less, to the laws that were given us there. Those who were faithful in all things there received greater blessings here, and those who were not faithful received less.” – Prophet Joseph Fielding Smith, Doctrines of Salvation, pg. 61

    To clearly lay this out, according to the former LDS prophets and apostles, they clearly taught that we all lived in pre-existence. Some of us were faithful and obedient in this previous life while others were not. Those who were obedient were blessed with white skin. Those who were disobedient were cursed with black skin.

    This part of the article seems to give us the impression that the “curse of Cain” and “blacks didn’t fight valiantly in pre-existence” were just ideas that floated around in the church. However, this isn’t the case. Both of these ideas were simultaneously taught by LDS Church prophets and apostles as official church doctrine for over 100 years.

    For most people, the injustice is what they cry out against. While I would agree with that, the problematic perspective I currently have is more focused on the theological level. It’s important to remember that eternal life is to dwell in the presence of God. And in order to “qualify” for eternal life (as Dallin Oaks puts it), I must receive the priesthoods (as a man) and receiving my endowment. Before 1978, blacks were prohibited from partaking of these ordinances. Therefore, they weren’t allowed to receive eternal life and dwell in the presence of God.

    When we boil it down and connect these dots, we understand that for 100+ years, the LDS Church taught God basically said to black people, “Sorry. You cannot enter into my presence because you have black skin.” This is not at all the God that I read about in the Bible.

    Galatians 3:26-28 “So in Christ Jesus you are all children of God through faith, for all of you who were baptized into Christ have clothed yourselves with Christ. There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.”

    God has never cared about the outward race, status, or gender of anyone. God’s Word is clear. Anyone who is truly in Christ is part of his church. Anyone who freely accepts His righteousness apart from works also receives the assurance of eternal life. This God of the Bible would never prohibit anyone from entering into His presence because of their skin color. Below are two other quotes from LDS leaders on this topic in case the previous quotes weren’t clear enough:

    “You must not think, from what I say, that I am opposed to slavery. No! The negro is damned, and is to serve his master till God chooses to remove the curse of Ham.” Prophet Brigham Young, New York Herald, May 4, 1855

    “Negroes in this life are denied the priesthood; under no circumstances can they hold this delegation of authority from the Almighty. The gospel message of salvation is not carried affirmatively to them…Negroes are not equal with other races where the receipt of certain spiritual blessings are concerned.” Apostle Bruce R. McConkie, Mormon Doctrine, p. 477, 1958

    This is the best concluding explanation that the Church has to offer. Some are content with this answer, while for others, it creates this uncomfortable and legitimate question:

    “The purpose of the prophets and apostles are to guide us in truth. If they were teaching us false doctrine about God and salvation for over 100 years, what assurance do I have that now all of their doctrines are true? What if they are still teaching a number of false doctrines due to “limited understanding” and have yet to receive the new “light and knowledge” from God? Is it wise for me to put my trust in men such as these and uphold them as true prophets of God?”

    When we honestly and critically think about this, does it make sense to believe that God would raise up modern day prophets who He knew would teach such hateful and false things about black people? While we do see a theme of black skin being a curse in LDS Scriptures (2 Nephi 30:6 & Abraham 1:26), we never see it anywhere in the Bible.

       John 17:17 “Sanctify them by the truth; your word is truth.”

       Psalm 119:105 “Your word is a lamp for my feet, a light on my path.”

    My encouragement to you is to put your trust in the Word of God and not in the words of men. The Word of God is the ultimate source of truth if that is what we are truly seeking. If you have doubts about whether or not you can trust the Bible, please check out my Bible Lesson, “Has The Bible Been Accurately Preserved Over Time?”

    Please let me know your thoughts, things you appreciated or things that you disagreed with in the comment section below. Thank you for reading and God bless!